Sunday, January 10, 2010

My response to Chetan Bhagat’s article on "Fighting for a Common Cause”

The original article can be found in the following link
http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/home/sunday-toi/all-that-matters/Ask-whats-our-cause-not-whats-mine/articleshow/5429006.cms#write

Chetan Bhagat in this article beautifully articulates that we have not been successful in introspecting about the targets we had set for ourselves a few decades ago. A very valid point and this is something we need to introspect on. After all, we cannot keep pushing the timeline by which we must achieve a measurable , sustainable growth.

The second part of the article speaks about what we must do in future to achieve the desired growth. Mr Bhagat speaks about voicing our opinions for a collective common cause to achieve a desired result. To a lay man this means that we need to voice our demands and opinions through a single channel or in another sense , vote on common grounds. Although this is a great idea ,this seems impractical in a country such as India. The reasons are mentioned below

- India’s economic growth has resulted in a skewed growth for certain sections. Now these sections that have already made some progress cannot blend their thought process with people from other sections of the society. For Eg : A man who has children studying in school and who has runs a successful business would be impressed by the thoughts and ideas of Kapil Sibal who wants to rope in Harvard and Stanford into India and might want him. Whereas I would rather want the government to provide goof healthcare insurance options to me and my family and might lean towards more of the leftist policies. The servant maid in my apartment would want a government that would provide better rice or what flour in the ration. She would be impressed with the policies of the DMK government in Tamil Nadu. Now , how on earth would we get all of them on the same platform to speak , debate and conclude on a common cause ? An anology to this is what Mr Bhagat specifically mentions about various NGO’s targeting different causes and the need for them to unite together !

- The second reason is India’s land size and the sheer impossibility to get everyone on a common platform. Let us consider the decision to vote to achieve results as a linear equation with a certain number of variables- now the greater the number of variables (causes we fight for) ,more difficult and time consuming it is to solve the problem(achieving atleast something if not everything).

I would like to quote several other reasons but would stop at this point. I am thrilled that intellectuals like Chetan Bhagat and Shashi Tharoor are thinking really hard to solve our problems and I hope they do succeed. This article is not to condemn Mr Bhagat’s line of thought. It is merely a counter argument. I strongly believe that arguing and debating would make us more intelligent individuals. I am also not sure if this article would reach all the people I intend it to reach. I certainly hope it does.

My Solution to the Problem

The problems faced by an area (typically a legislative assembly )can be addressed by forming an Area Association comprising of really smart and hardworking people located in the area. They can understand the needs of the people. The landscape of the area would be uniform and the professions of the people would not be very diverse. For Eg : In an urban area we can elect a person who is ready to solve issues of sanitation and roads . Similarly in a village , a person who understands the minimum support price concept for crops and issues of fertilizer prize can be elected.

So the real solution is to group people by area or locality rather than by their demands. Why should a farmer in Maharashtra who is fighting (for or )against BT cotton lose his sleep over the issue of farm land flooding near the Cauvery Delta ?

I hope I am atleast partially correct :-)

8 comments:

Abhishek Ramani said...

Raghav,

Thanks for the interesting post.

I have a couple of comments.

1. Your thought on tailoring a solution to fit the need at a grassroot level is indeed an interesting thought. You're spot on in the observation that what is observed to be a good solution for one may prove to be not as effective to another, unless it is applied in a way that the second person gets the most benefit from it.

2. However, consider what could happen if we institute independent factions working at grass root levels with varying agendas? They would have only their priorities in mind and all decisions/actions they take would be solely to further interests. What happens to the larger interest of the community/India? I cant help but think that such a divisive policy would only infuse more confusion and introduce further scope for manipulative tactics along geographical/economical lines (as if we dont have enough of that already!)

All said and done, no man is an island and no change can be effected unless it starts from the lowest rung of the ladder. I think what we need is a bridge between the two extremes - monarchy and a free for all situation - and i believe it starts from the individual. You and i become a little bit more socially responsible and we've made a mark on the image of the country. Sure its a small, almost negligible mark but we gotta start somewhere!

Someone follows you, and someone else follows me - the chain might just continue! I sure hope it does!

ok - i realise i am running the risk of having my comment as long as your article! Think i'll stop now :)

Raghav Parthasarathy said...

@Abhishek
I agree with you that the larger interest of the country is of utmost importance. I believe that this should be taken care by the MP and not by an MLA.. The MLA needs to perform the duties I have mentioned in my blog whereas an MP would focus on the larger issues.. Although this seems fairly difficult in our country where the centre and state governments transfer their responsibilities to each other ! :-)

You sum up a brilliant point when you say "I cant help but think that such a divisive policy would only infuse more confusion and introduce further scope for manipulative tactics along geographical/economical lines (as if we dont have enough of that already!)"

Thanks for your valuable comment. It has brought out yet another important aspect of the problem at hand.

Balu R said...

"The problems faced by an area (typically a legislative assembly )can be addressed by forming an Area Association comprising of really smart and hardworking people located in the area"
Theoretically the MLA, Councilors, Bureaucrats(IAS, IPS officers) were supposed to be the smart and hardworking individuals who should take of problems that plague an area. Why do you think this people's association will get different results to what our normal election and appointment process didnt result in ?

But i totally agree with you that fighting for a common cause is not practical both for size of nation as well as ambiguity in defining a common cause ..

Raghav Parthasarathy said...

@Balu
You are spot on when you say that "the MLA, Councilors, Bureaucrats(IAS, IPS officers) were supposed to be the smart and hardworking individuals who should take of problems that plague an area"..
However , they are tied to the government and don't have a free hand. The district collector of Nagapatanam did a super job after the Tsunami.. But he was transferred by the next TN govt.. So if we can have people who can independent from the government machinery , it would be good.. Unlike MLAs(who may or may not be relected) or beaurocrats (who can be transferred anytime), area associations always work for a particular area and know the needs much better..

Harshal @ Snehapadma said...

Hi Raghav,

You are talking about the Local Governance. It's already there in the form of Panchayat Samitis, Municipal Corporations which works in tandem with bureaucrats and engineers to solve local problems.

MLAs, MPs (should) focus on matters important for State and Union of India.

Raghav Parthasarathy said...

@Harshal
I agree with you that there is a mechanism in place. But my point here is to make it more effective. When we look around us we realize that the exisiting machinery hasn't been as successful as it should have been. My reply to the previous comment (Balu's comment) emphasizes on this...

Anonymous said...

[url=http://welcome-casino.aoaoaxxx.ru][img]http://s55.radikal.ru/i147/0912/3d/62ecfa4cfb24.jpg[/img][/url]

[IMG]http://s44.radikal.ru/i105/0912/3d/c3f5c104cbf9.jpg[/IMG]


[url=http://welcome-casino.aoaoaxxx.ru][img]http://i011.radikal.ru/0912/d6/e2d4895b3eac.jpg[/img][/url]














































[u][b]We can be found by these keywords:[/b][/u]
[url=http://welcome-casino.aoaoaxxx.ru/sitemap.html]casinos gratis en espanol [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/little-river-casino-michigan.html]casino sur net [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/online-casino-no-deposit-bonus.html]loteria y casinos resultado de la quiniela de argentina [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/new-casino-bonuses.html]tunica ms casino room [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/monte-carlo-casino-las-vegas.html]hollywood casino streveport [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/imdb-plot-the-casino-job-2009.html]cupon casino rio [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/view-casino.html]galeria casino monte gordo [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/bay-biloxi-casino.html]loteria casino argentina [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/spa-casino-palm-springs.html]casino in indiana [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/presque-downs-casino.html]casino descarga gratis jugar diversion [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/gold-strike-casino.html]uk casino online [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/clay-casino.html]loteria nacional de beneficencia y casinos [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/casino-poker-tournament.html]internet gambling casino [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/the-online-casino.html]juego casino on line [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/green-valley-casino.html]casino castell perelada [/url]
[url=http://vegasonlines.net/soaring-eagle-casino-mt-pleasant-michigan.html]best online casino payouts [/url]
juego casino mendoza
[b]juego gratis casino online[/b]
casino computer game
juego casino onlain gratis
[b]resort casino tunica[/b]
promocion casino linea
[u]aladdin resort and casino[/u]
terraza casino madrid menu aceite
casino ganar en las maquina
[b]jugar casino online gratis[/b]
casino card games
vegas casino best comps

Anonymous said...

[url=http://seghan.ru/go.php?sid=35][img]http://s003.radikal.ru/i203/1001/17/1008f12c7936.jpg[/img][/url]












[url=http://vjzvmeu.il.gp/]buying cigarettes across michigan state line [/url]
organic cigarettes buy buying cigarettes at age 13 buy 555 cigarettes
[url=http://wcsoius.biz.co.nl/]the legal age to buy cigarettes [/url]
buy single packs of cigarettes buy wholesale cigarettes with money order buy pink elephant cigarettes
[url=http://powjxun.wieder-mal.de/]buy cheap old gold cigarettes online [/url]
buy used cigarette boats europe buy cigarettes 18 buy cigarettes from kentucky
[url=http://tyouhca.xn--geglckt-q2a.de/]buy smoking cigarettes [/url]
illinois taxes and buying cigarettes online cigarette lighter splitter best buy buy chunghwa cigarette
[url=http://ubpscsn.pro.ac/]buying cigarettes in italy [/url]
buy cigarettes from japan e cigarette order buying cigarettes from indian reservations
[url=http://tyouhca.xn--geglckt-q2a.de/sitemap.html]buy lucky strike cigarettes [/url]
buy cigarette indian reservation where to buy clove cigarettes online id to buy cigarettes
[url=http://deuaexj.naheliegend.de/]laws about buying cigarettes online [/url]
to buy discount cigarettes buy english cigarettes on line age to buy cigarettes
[url=http://vjzvmeu.il.gp/sitemap.html]cigarettes buy on line [/url]
best site to buy cigarettes buy e cigarette in cigarettes prices buy state
[url=http://wcsoius.biz.co.nl/sitemap.html]what age you can buy cigarettes [/url]
11 buy cigarette marlboro buy marlboro menthol cigarettes buy cigarettes with paypal uk
[url=http://vonzura.misslich.de/sitemap.html]buy lucky strike cigarettes [/url]
buy marshall mcgearty cigarettes buy flavoured cigarettes buying electric cigarette

Locations of visitors to this page